Onana Dropped or Rested? Manchester United’s Bold Goalkeeping Decision Raises Eyebrows

In a surprising move, Manchester United boss Ruben Amorim opted to leave André Onana out of the matchday squad against Newcastle United. Whether it was a tactical rest or a performance-related drop, Onana's absence—even from the bench—has sparked intense speculation.

Roy Keane Questions Onana’s Future

Ahead of the clash, former United captain Roy Keane weighed in, suggesting Amorim's patience with the Cameroonian goalkeeper may have run out. While Keane acknowledged United’s defensive improvements, he didn't shy away from highlighting Onana’s high-profile errors in recent games.

Just last week, Onana faced heavy criticism for his mistakes in the match against Lyon, where his poor decision-making directly led to goals. These recurring blunders are becoming difficult to ignore for fans and pundits alike.

 Paul Robinson Highlights Importance of Man-Management

Former England international Paul Robinson also chimed in, stressing the importance of good man-management when players are underperforming. He suggested that temporarily removing Onana from the spotlight could be beneficial—not just for the player’s confidence but also for team harmony.

“When a goalkeeper hits a rough patch, it’s crucial to manage the situation carefully,” Robinson said. “Giving him a break can sometimes reset his focus and relieve team pressure.”

 What’s Next for Onana?

At 29, André Onana is at a critical juncture in his career. His experience is undeniable, but frequent errors are beginning to overshadow his strengths. Whether this decision by Amorim signals a short-term tactical adjustment or a long-term shift remains to be seen.

 Final Thoughts

This bold call by Amorim might just be a wake-up call for Onana—or the beginning of a new chapter in United’s goalkeeping department. Either way, it underscores the high stakes and intense scrutiny that come with playing at the top level.